Should a creator with 500,000 followers be treated like a TV channel during an election? France just answered.
What the French Arcom just decided about content creators and political pluralism, why it matters for the European AVMSD revision, and what the UMICC and the EIMA are pushing for.
TLDR. On 19 November 2026, the French regulator Arcom published its recommendation for the 2027 presidential election. For the first time, certain content creators will have to comply with political pluralism rules usually reserved for TV and radio channels. The creators concerned are those whose channel meets the legal definition of an on-demand audiovisual media service (SMAD). Three qualitative criteria apply: content (regularly covering public-interest topics), impact (audience comparable to that of a media outlet), and regularity. Enforcement runs by complaint, not by systematic monitoring, with graduated sanctions. Fashion, sport, cooking or gaming creators who occasionally mention the election are not concerned. Neither are audio podcasts, nor campaign-propaganda accounts. Some of the UMICC positions have been heard, but two issues remain open: the broad SMAD interpretation, and the lack of public thresholds. France is moving a few months before the European Commission is expected to publish its AVMSD revision. The French reading risks becoming a European precedent. This is why I am pushing for clear, measurable, cumulative criteria that recognise what a creator actually is.
Context: why Europe should pay attention
I have been working on this question for months, with the Union des Métiers de l’Influence et des Créateurs de Contenu (UMICC) and the European Influencer Marketing Alliance (EIMA). The question is deceptively simple: should a content creator with a large audience be considered a media outlet?
It’s a complex question, and Brussels has not answered yet. The European Commission is expected to publish its revision of the Audiovisual Media Services Directive (AVMSD, or « directive SMA » in French) in early 2027. The qualification of creators is one of the central questions on the table, and UMICC and EIMA have been regularly contributing to the debate so far.
France seems now to be moving first.
Through the 2027 presidential election, the French media regulator Arcom has just published a recommendation that applies political pluralism obligations to certain creators. This is the first time such obligations extend beyond TV and radio in France. And because EU regulators often look at the French model when drafting European texts, I think this matters far beyond our borders.
What the Arcom recommendation actually says
The new rules will apply from 16 March 2027 (equity between candidates) and then from 5 April 2027 (strict equality). They target content creators whose channel legally qualifies as a service of on-demand audiovisual media (SVOD, or « SMAD » in French). In practice, and to make it simple, a creator with a public catalogue of videos accessible on demand, on a platform like YouTube, meets the definition.
Who is concerned. Creators who meet 3 qualitative criteria:
- Content. They regularly cover topics of public interest or societal debate: news, politics, economy, interviews with public figures.
- Impact. Their audience is significant and comparable to that of an audiovisual media outlet. In our last UMICC meeting with the Arcom, the regulator clarified that impact would be assessed by combining follower count and views, with an informal reference around 1 million.
- Regularity. A single viral video is not enough. The channel must have an established pattern of public-interest content and high reach.
Who is not concerned. Three exemptions matter here, and they are often missed in the media coverage of the past 24 hours:
- Fashion, sport, cooking, lifestyle or gaming creators who occasionally mention the election are not in scope.
- Accounts explicitly dedicated to a candidate’s or party’s propaganda fall under a separate electoral regime, not this recommendation.
- Audio podcasts are explicitly excluded. Only video content is in scope (what about static content?).
How it will be enforced. No systematic monitoring of speaking time, as is the case for TV and radio. The Arcom will intervene only after a complaint (saisine) or an obvious breach. Graduated sanctions apply: warning, formal notice (mise en demeure), then financial penalty in case of repeated breaches. Creators concerned are treated as “editors” in the legal sense, which also puts them under editorial responsibility.
Where the UMICC was heard
The UMICC has been in dialogue with the Arcom on this topic for months. Some of our positions have been heard. The explicit exemption for creators without a regular political line is one. The focus on impact rather than followers alone is another. The control-by-complaint model, lighter than the TV / radio regime, is a third. These matter, because they protect the vast majority of creators from being pulled into a framework that was not designed for them.
Two issues that in my view are still open
1. The SVOD classification goes too far
The Arcom keeps a broad reading of the SVOD definition. In practice, a YouTube channel, a TikTok account or an Instagram profile with a public video catalogue can be qualified as an on-demand audiovisual media service. From our perspective at the UMICC and the EIMA, this stretches the category beyond its original intent.
A content creator is not an audiovisual editor in the sense of a TV channel. The relationship a creator has with their community, the formats they use, the lack of editorial resources, the dependency on platform for the diffusion of their content, and the absence of a proper linear programming all set them apart from the broadcasting model. If a category is needed, it should be specific to creators, with obligations calibrated to what they actually do.
This becomes particularly important now because the European Commission is about to release its AVMSD revision. If the French reading becomes the European precedent, we risk extending to all large creators a set of obligations that were designed for TV: protection of minors, European works quotas, financial contributions to audiovisual funds, reporting duties. For independent creators, often working alone or in small teams, this would be unworkable.
2. The lack of clear thresholds, and a legal question about the scope of the recommendation itself
The Arcom has chosen qualitative criteria without clear public thresholds. I understand the legal caution behind this choice, but the absence of thresholds leaves the door open to very broad interpretations. In practice, nothing prevents a campaign team or an internet group from filing a complaint against a creator with 300,000 followers who mentioned the election two or three times. The Arcom will not have the resources to handle all these complaints, and the pressure will fall back on the creators themselves.
Lawyers from the UMICC legal committee are also raising a separate but related question: can a recommendation from an administrative authority impose obligations that go beyond what Parliament delegated in the law? As a matter of principle, an administrative authority cannot modify the law or create obligations outside its competence. This is a debate that may eventually reach the Conseil d’État.
What creators are saying
Content creators have been under growing pressure for months to take political positions, and they face waves of online hate when they do, and sometimes when they don’t. Female creators, who make up close to 8 out of 10 French creators, are the first targets.
In the hours following the publication of the Arcom recommendation, several concerned creators reacted publicly. Some of them very strongly. I understand this reaction. The line between legitimate electoral oversight and interference with a creator’s editorial freedom is a fine one, and the current ambiguity might make that line even harder to see. Regulating in a way that could creates new attack surfaces for an already exposed community is a real risk, especially for women.
What we could do to improve the situation
I believe a workable framework exists, and that it needs to be defined now, before it is defined in Brussels. Our proposal at UMICC and EIMA rests on 3 cumulative criteria, measurable and designed to match the reality of the creator economy:
- Editorial focus. At least 30% of the content published over the last 12 months must be dedicated to public-interest subjects (news, politics, economy, societal debate). A channel where politics is a side topic, an occasional reaction to the news, should not qualify.
- Real impact. A reach of at least 5% of the country’s internet population, measured by views rather than by followers. In France, that would mean approximately 3 million people reached (for example, with the 1M threshold mentioned by the Arcom we are close to 2%). Views are a better indicator of actual influence than the size of the community, which can be inherited, dormant or inflated.
- Regularity. At least 25 publications per year. A single viral video, or a reaction to a one-off news cycle, should not qualify a creator as a media outlet.
The three criteria work together, on a cumulative basis. A channel that meets one but not the others should not fall under the regime. This matters because the current Arcom framework, by relying on 3 qualitative criteria without quantitative anchors, leaves each one subject to interpretation. The UMICC / EIMA proposal addresses the same 3 dimensions (editorial focus, impact, regularity), but it gives each one a public, verifiable threshold.
I know some will say that fixing thresholds is politically risky, because they can always be criticised as arbitrary. I think the opposite is true. Thresholds create legal certainty for creators, limit discretionary enforcement, and protect the small and mid-sized creators who make up the vast majority of the ecosystem. They also give regulators a defendable public line, rather than a case-by-case appreciation that is easier to contest.
Why this matters for Europe
Regulating political information online during a presidential election is legitimate, and in my view necessary. Creators who build their business on information carry responsibilities that scale with their audience. On that principle, I agree with the Arcom.
But a short-lived electoral recommendation from one national regulator should not, by a side effect, decide the legal status of content creators across Europe. The AVMSD revision is the right legal vehicle for that debate, with the right time horizon and the right range of stakeholders. The French recommendation is a signal, not a settlement.
We will keep working on this, with the Arcom, with the European Commission, and with our peers across the industry.
Publié dans: Influence
